Agenda June 30, 20212Desired Outcome: CDS Design Team understands desired functionality, requirements, and challenges to building a CDS tool that can be integrated into EHR systems.
|
---|
Partner Talking PointsDesired Outcome: CDS Design Team understands desired functionality, requirements, and challenges to building a CDS tool that can be integrated into EHR systems.
|
---|
RESOURCES |
---|
Project Teams
NACHC Informatics Team | Alphora | AllianceChicago | El Rio | Fenway | Montefiore | Ohio ACHC |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Julia Skapik (Deactivated)Clinician SME, familiar with EHR Pedro B Carneiro (Deactivated) Data Scientist familiar with EHR, HIV Data Raymonde Uy (Unlicensed) Physician SME on Informatics John GreshData Management Andrea Price Old Account (Deactivated)Project Manager | Bryn Rhodes | Andrew Hamilton Shelly Sital Dr. Timothy Long (Clinical SME/User), the Director of Nursing, HIV Care Team, Medical Assistants, and Lab Director For most of the technical components, that would be AllianceChicago staff (Clinical Informatics). At the health center, it would be the EMR manager who would ensure the order was created correctly for the SME user to utilize in-house. | Sudha Nagalingam, MD- Clinician SME, Familiar with EHR Greg Raglow, MD- Physician SME Informatics Dustin Holloway, MPH- Data Management/Analytcis Erin Dougherty, MPH- Grants Management Erika Solis- HIV Care Coordinator | Clinical Champions - Dr. Alex Gonzalez, Medical Director
Dr. Brian Bakofen, Medical Population Health | Viraj Patel, MD, MPH – Project lead and SME on clinical care for HIV prevention and treatment Uriel Felson, MD, MS – Project leadership team and SME on clinical care for HIV prevention and treatment Sharon Rikin, MD, MS – Project leadership team and SME on quality improvement in health systems Robert Beil, MD Debjyoti Datta, MBBS, MPH – Project coordinator Helen Farren – EPIC IT Analyst responsible for Adult Medicine Michael Rinke, MD – Stakeholder for quality improvement at primary care sites Vanessa Protamo, MD -- Stakeholder for clinical care at primary care sites Manuja Mather, MD – Medical Director and Champion for one primary care site Tamara Nawar, MD – CHampion for one primary care site | Lower Lights CHC Dr. Lynnette Palmer, Quality Director, familiar with EHR Richard Harris, Data Analyst, familiar with EHR Southeast CHC Nick Nelson, MPH, NP-C SME advisor, familiar with the EHR |
EHR | AthenaPractice | Epic | AthenaHealth | Epic | NextGen |
AllianceChicago Workflows
AllianceChicago CDS Worksheet
Panel |
---|
1.Briefly describe the current approach to measuring and supporting the care team in HIV testing and follow up in your organization. In our clinical content in athenaPractice, there are CDS tools that alert the provider whether or not the patient should have an HIV screening or for routine testing in the general population. This is in the adult preventative care form and other forms such as the prenatal clinical content. It is always on the flow sheets to see the results if the HIV test was completed. There are order sets that allow individual providers to check one box for STI testing, which includes HIV, Hep-B, Hep-C, gonorrhea, chlamydia and syphilis. 2. Talk about the process you would have to engage in to design and get care team buy in for the design of content and interfaces to support HIV testing and follow up guidelines and workflow improvements. It would be interesting to design a new workflow where during intake the care team screens the patient for diabetes, HIV, etc. This could include standing orders that automatically order the HIV test to be a part of bloodwork that is being requested. Nursing staff in addition to the provider is then in the workflow ordering the tests. There may also be Point of Care testing for HIV or the regular testing completed by the intake person. This would be additional responsibility placed on those care team members, but then it reduces the burden on the provider (especially as this is then routine, and the provider may be occupied with other more urgent screenings). We should be making HIV testing as one of the routine processes. 3. Identify the team, including titles, who would work on this project from the clinical and technical sides. Who are the technical leads? Are there any external vendors? Clinical SMEs and users? Other leaders/champions? Dr. Timothy Long (Clinical SME/User), the Director of Nursing, HIV Care Team, Medical Assistants, and Lab Director. For most of the technical components, that would be AllianceChicago staff (Clinical Informatics). At the health center, it would be the EMR manager who would ensure the order was created correctly for the SME user to utilize in-house. |
Panel |
---|
4. Discuss your technical path to implement new tools or significant improvements to your EHR/pop health tools to support HIV testing and follow up. Include approvals, costs, impacts, testing, vendor involvement if any. If there are unanswered questions you need to answer, OK to list here. The technical path involved the following milestones:
These stages of our technical path – Discovery, Design, Development, Testing, and Deployment – are indicative of our standard informatics processes for health IT software solutions, based on healthcare user experience best-practices. Stakeholders involved included internal AllianceChicago clinical, implementation, and technical Subject Matter Experts, as well as external Health Center clinical Subject Matter Experts. This team of cross-functional expertise enabled the translation of the USPSTF recommendations into real-world CDS solutions and workflow recommendations. These stakeholders were informed and engaged at each stage, to ensure the project was on course and approving next steps for the overall jobs-to-be-done.
Yes – clinical decision support (CDS) can be built within the EHR application we use, involving product-specific programming capabilities enabled by the vendor. In addition, we have experience in CDS development integration projects where we connect the EHR to CDS engines outside the EHR application, for real-time referencing of outside CDS guidance while the user is within the EHR experience. |
El Rio Health Clinical Workflow
Panel |
---|
Described are the opportunities to engage with a patient around the clinic encounter.
Check in: Rooming: |
Panel |
---|
MD/Clinician Extender visit: Post-visit with staff (in clinic): Pharmacist: |
Panel |
---|
Post-visit/Care Coordination: |
Info |
---|
Proposed Intervention We would like a streamlined approach to HIV counseling and testing – currently we are using the care guidelines |
Panel |
---|
1.Briefly describe the current approach to measuring and supporting the care team in HIV testing and follow up in your organization.
2. Talk about the process you would have to engage in to design and get care team buy in for the design of content and interfaces to support HIV testing and follow up guidelines and workflow improvements.
|
Panel |
---|
4. Discuss your technical path to implement new tools or significant improvements to your EHR/pop health tools to support HIV testing and follow up. Include approvals, costs, impacts, testing, vendor involvement if any. If there are unanswered questions you need to answer, OK to list here. A. Do you have a portal where you can use FHIR applications inside your EHR?
B. Do you have a CDS engine to build content in your EHR?
|
Fenway Clinical and Data Workflows - TBD
Fenway CDS Worksheet
Panel |
---|
1.Briefly describe the current approach to measuring and supporting the care team in HIV testing and follow up in your organization. Monthly reports are distributed that aggregate the number of tests completed as well as HIV positive tests. The reports are stratified by different demographics (e.g., age, race, ethnicity, gender, etc.). Care teams conduct daily huddles for patients seen that day. The huddles review any clinical services that a patient is due for (e.g., HIV test, depression screen, etc.) The huddle forms are accessible in the patient’s charts. 2. Talk about the process you would have to engage in to design and get care team buy in for the design of content and interfaces to support HIV testing and follow up guidelines and workflow improvements. We have several workgroup and team meetings that provide an opportunity to discuss workflow improvements. There is a weekly clinical computing meeting that consists of clinical and technical staff. Additionally, we have a monthly HIV meeting where clinical issues and workflows are discussed. |
Panel |
---|
4. Discuss your technical path to implement new tools or significant improvements to your EHR/pop health tools to support HIV testing and follow up. Include approvals, costs, impacts, testing, vendor involvement if any. If there are unanswered questions you need to answer, OK to list here.
Do you have a portal where you can use FHIR applications inside your EHR?
Do you have a CDS engine to build content in your EHR?
|
Montefiore Clinical Workflow
Montefiore Data Workflow
Montefiore CDS Worksheet
Panel |
---|
1. Briefly describe the current approach to measuring and supporting the care team in HIV testing and follow up in your organization. The current approach to supporting the care team in HIV testing is – Best Practice Advisory (BPA) Prompts. We have an established multidisciplinary network of HIV providers in primary care, developing comprehensive program for HIV prevention with PrEP 2. Talk about the process you would have to engage in to design and get care team buy in for the design of content and interfaces to support HIV testing and follow up guidelines and workflow improvements. Meeting with primary care quality improvement (QI) committee – Describing the problem ( showing data about relative low testing rate) Making BPA more user friendly – Discuss BPA modification or other types of CDS à get feedback from the committee Talking to IT Team for adult ambulatory EPIC care – discussing feasibility and modifications |
Panel |
---|
4. Discuss your technical path to implement new tools or significant improvements to your EHR/pop health tools to support HIV testing and follow up. Include approvals, costs, impacts, testing, vendor involvement if any. If there are unanswered questions you need to answer, OK to list here. IT/EPIC Ticket/request à reviewed in Adult Medicine IT request prioritization meetings - prioritized and assigned to analysts for final approval by Matt Berger, MD
|
Ohio ACHC Clinical Workflow
Ohio ACHC Data Workflow
Ohio PCA CDS Worksheet
HIV CDS Objectives | Southeast Health
|
Standing Orders or Pre-Built order sets in EHR | · Don’t currently have a standing order for HIV Screening o Need to figure out how standing orders can be built into HER (Shawn) or clarify for nurses, could be an MA as well- how they do standing orders · Standing order could be based on the identification of certain risk factors, scores on risk assessment questionnaire, or patient request. · Might have a SO already for HIV, need to check on this. |
Utilize Patient Visit Planning/ Huddle Reports | · SE would start with patients here in the huddle. · HIV screening flag turned on in Azara 5/18/21. Staff is already familiar with this. |
Identify opportunities or decision support in your EHR specific to different staff members | · Providers: a pop-up reminder during the lab ordering process for patients that are due for the once in a lifetime screening · Risk assessment module that could give a score for individual patients and could prompt a high risk reminder for someone who needs additional HIV testing. Risk assessment would need to be built and then set for every 90 days for example. Currently have a risk assessment for HIV- tied to recommending PrEP. · Nurses/MAs: Pop up/flag in the check out section that lists the orders placed by the provider · Note- this is ideal, not sure what all is possible |
Utilize EHR tools such as system alerts and patient reminders to alert staff of patient who meet eligibility criteria | · Color change or a flag for different staff. MA or provider can review- Not sure if this is possible. · We currently do NOT have a preventative maintenance dashboard. If our update has one, then HIV screening could be on this and the frequency could be based on other risk factors that would be identified in the chart, possible through an HIV risk assessment questionnaire. |
Identify the frequency of EHR alerts (annually for some, more often for others). Include optional overrides | · Once for all patients · Every 3 months for people that have an opiate use disorder dx · Every 3 months for people with a high risk sexual behavior diagnosis |
Use EMR and Azara to monitor patients with HIV dx | · The HIV/PrEP care manager and RN team currently use a self-made registry to follow HIV positive patients · A registry pulled from the EHR has been requested from data management · Azara would be great to use, but need HIV module? Review the measure list for the HIV add on module. |
EMR Templates/AVS for education on PrEP | · Would need to create an HIV risk assessment template. · Need to find out if Nextgen update will have something that would work for risk assessment or any other PrEP specific modules etc. · If there was an HIV risk assessment template, then a certain score could trigger a pop-up for HIV testing every 3 months or a pop up to offer PrEP. |
OTHER NOTES | Might use risk assessment or pop up for HepC as well as HIV. |
HIV CDS Objectives | Lower Lights Christian Health Center
|
Standing Orders or Pre-Built order sets in EHR | · MA to be able to automatically order an HIV test if it’s left off a lab order. Current alerts and flags are old and do not disappear when the test is ordered. Possible that Nextgen does not pick up on all alerts. Azara PVP alert fills in here. |
Utilize Patient Visit Planning/ Huddle Reports | · Azara PVP alert is on for HIV Lifetime Screening at LL. Azara report will not help with lab only visit because its not an appointment. |
Identify opportunities or decision support in your EHR specific to different staff members | · Not sure that Nextgen can pick up on test needing to be ordered. Visit types of telehealth, lab visit etc. · There is a screening summary section in Nextgen that HIV could maybe be added to and checked off like other preventative screenings (PAP, mammogram, hearing). Can review drug use and other risk factors here as well that could inform screening. |
Utilize EHR tools such as system alerts and patient reminders to alert staff of patient who meet eligibility criteria | · Currently have an alert for HIV already but it doesn’t work well and isn’t updated so is often incorrect. Providers do not use for HIV specifically. |
Identify the frequency of EHR alerts (annually for some, more often for others). Include optional overrides | · Just once for the HIV Lifetime screening. Not sure about the high risk for HIV alert in HER because they can’t really configure the lifetime one at this time. Would want 90 days retest if this could be configured. · Maybe can turn on an alert in Azara for this? Not sure about OUD HIV Measure or others. · PrEP risk assessment from Columbia University |
Use EMR and Azara to monitor patients with HIV dx | · HIV coordinator gets referral for positive HIV patients (refer to Equitas for txt). Not an alert or notification coming up for HIV dx. · HIV reports in Azara and can see who is newly diagnosed. · Would want an alert for a patient that has HIV if possible. |
EMR Templates/AVS for education on PrEP | · Nextgen has a pt. education tab where you can add whatever you’d like for the MA to print off. Not sure about the PrEP education. Providers use different resources. · Could load better HIV and PrEP info in there and more languages are needed. |
OTHER NOTES | · . Care Guidelines- providers do not want to use so it isn’t turned on. Can’t be personalized by providers. |
Discussion Questions
Anchor | ||||
---|---|---|---|---|
|
Q | Item | Notes | Action Items |
---|---|---|---|
1. | What would you like a Clinical Decision Support routine to do? | ||
2. | Discussion with the technical ppl on what their protocols are for integrating the CDS into their system
| ||
3. | Data form and manner including whether you capture:
| ||
4. | Follow Up/Next Steps | ||
5. | Parking lot for later | ||
Partner Profiles in Brief (These are estimates and do not need to match the data pulls. The timeframe is any time frame that is convenient for you)
HIV Prevalence/New Infections per year/percent of pop that lives with HIV | Demographics (however you define them - your categories) | Substance Abuse Profile/Rate | |||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Race | Ethnicity | Gender Identity | Sex Assigned at Birth | Sexual Orientation | |||
AllianceChicago | |||||||
El Rio | Percent of Health Center Population Living with HIV/AIDS: 1.5% (2019) New HIV Diagnoses in 2019: 62 (this number includes new infections diagnosed within the organization and outside referrals to El Rio SIA upon a positive HIV diagnosis outside of our El Rio system) | 2% - Asian 0.08% - Native Hawaiian 0.16% - Other PI 4.45% - African American 7.26% - American Indian 80.87% - White 0.99% - More than one Race 4.38% - Unreported/Refused All Race Data: UDS, 2019 | 57% Hispanic/Latinx (UDS, 2019) 42% Non-Hispanic (UDS, 2019) 1% Refused (UDS, 2019) | 0.55% - Transgender (UDS, 2019) | 41%- Male (UDS, 2019) 59%- Female (UDS,2019) | 3.1%- Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual (UDS, 2019) 1.7% -Other/Something Else (UDS, 2019) | 3.95% Other Substance-related Disorders (excluding tobacco) and Alcohol-related Disorders (UDS, 2019) |
Fenway | |||||||
Montefiore | |||||||
Ohio | Lower Lights CHC Health Center Patients living with HIV - 0.19% (21 pts) New HIV Dx: UDS 2020 Southeast CHC Health Center Patients living with HIV - 0.46% (37 pts) New HIV Dx: 10 (HIV Linkage to Care measure) 2020 UDS Data | Lower Lights CHC 2% Asian 1% Other PI 22% Black/AA 49% White 14% more than one race 12% Unreported/Refused 2020 UDS Data Southeast CHC 0.8% Asian 0.05% Native Hawaiian 0.05% Other PI 30.8% Black/AA 0.4% AI/AN 62.2% White 3.1% More than one race 2.6% Unreported/Refused 2020 UDS Data | Lower Lights CHC 15% Hispanic/Latino 77% Non Hispanic Latino 8% Unreported/Refused 2020 UDS Data Southeast CHC 2.2% Hispanic/Latino 97.5% Non Hispanic Latino 0.3% Unreported/Refused 2020 UDS Data | Lower Lights CHC 0.18% Transgender 2020 UDS Data Southeast CHC 0.73% Transgender 2020 UDS Data | Lower Lights CHC 3894 (36%) Male, 5664 (53%) Female 2020 UDS Data Southeast CHC 3977 (50.2%) assigned male 3737 (49.7%) assigned female 2020 UDS Data | Lower Lights CHC Lesbian/gay (1%) Bisexual (0.8%) Something else /don’t know (15%) 2020 UDS Data Southeast CHC 3.1% Lesbian/gay 4.6% Bisexual 1.1% Something else/don't know 2020 UDS Data | Lower Lights CHC 6.0% Other Substance-related disorders (excluding tobacco use and alcohol-related disorders) Southeast CHC 26.2% Other Substance-related disorders (excluding tobacco use and alcohol-related disorders) 2020 UDS Data |